PPND - the Platform for Neolithic Radiocarbon Dates

 

35°52′06 N    38°23'36'' E   Download OxCal File

Apart from Mureybet, Abu Hureyra is one of the few sites on the middle Euphrates where Epipalaeolithic and early Neolithic layers have been found. The radiocarbon dates of the Epipalaeolithic layers (Fig. 1) correlate quite well with the stratigraphy. Only OxA 475 of the uppermost layer E 396 and BM 1719R seem to belong to a transitional phase to the late PPNB settlement. [1]The range of the radiocarbon dates of the Epipalaeolithic layers indicates an occupation of the settlement between 11220 and 10750 BC.

All radiocarbon dated domesticated cereals (red oval) that were found in the Epipalaeolithic layers seem to be intrusive from upper layers. They were all dated to a time range between 7450-7070 BC. The only exceptions are the “domesticated-like” rye seeds considered by Hillman to be fully domesticated (Hillman 2000; cf. Weiss et al. 2006). It is striking that no other cereal except rye seems to have been domesticated during the Epipalaeolithic. The uncalibrated radiocarbon dates of the Neolithic settlement of Abu Hureyra (Fig.2) cluster into two phases: samples dating to the older phase were predominantly found in Trenches B and D, and those from the younger phase from Trenches E and G, as was noticed by Moore (2000:257). [2]

Fig. 2 also shows that Trench C likewise dates from Phase 2A. Even the radiocarbon date BM 1425 of Trench C does not overlap after calibration with all the later dates of the second phase, which overlap in the 1-σ range up to OxA 6418: 8115+/-80.[3] The obviously recent date OxA 877: 8300+/-150 BP of Trench D, which lays in the range of the later dates of Trench E and G before calibration, overlaps after calibration in the
1-σ range with the older dates of Trench D.

Up to April 2009 only one date from Trench A had been published. It clearly is from phase 2B.

This shift from Trenches B, C and D to Trenches A, E and G is also visible after calibration, though due to the probability ranges of the calibrated radiocarbon dates the separation of the dates becomes less clear.

 

Phase 2A:

The main occupation of Phase 2A probably starts at about 7760 BC or, as two AMS-dates of cereals show, even later, at about 7600 BC. Phase 2A lasts until around 7440 BC (cf. Moore 2000:256).[4]

Phase 2B:

The second concentration of dates starts around 7400 BC and lasts until 7100 BC. Although most of the radiocarbon-dated cereals from Phase 2B were found in the Epipalaeolithic layers, they were certainly displaced from upper Neolithic layers. They point to a clearly distinguishable Neolithic phase and correlate well with other in situ samples of this phase.

It is thus possible to include these “aberrant” samples in the dating of Phase 2B. Whereas the charcoal samples scatter over a wide range, the cereal samples cluster in a narrow time frame. The latest date (OxA 1931: 7890+/-90 BP) comes from Level 2 of Trench G, but the sample is probably displaced. Like the other intrusive cereal samples of the Epipalaeolithic layers, it further illustrates the extensive dislocations due to pits and buildings dug from later into earlier layers.

To sum up, two Neolithic phases can be distinguished that document a shift of the used space within the settlement. According to the radiocarbon dates, it can be postulated that settlement activities shifted from Trenches B, D, and C (Phase 2A) to Trench E, G, and A (Phase 2B). There is only one date (BM 1424) of Phase 2A Trench B that points to a use during the later Phase 2B.

Due to the large time ranges, the radiocarbon dates function like a scrim diffuser and suggest a “continuous” occupation. However it is not possible to determine whether the settlement was permanently occupied or whether there were instead several short occupation phases interrupted by brief periods of abandonment.

The separation of two absolute chronological Neolithic phases is supported by the observation of Moore et al. (2000:257), who distinguished Phase 2B from Phase 2A essentially because of the dominance of sheep and goat in Phase 2B, in contrast to Phase 2A, during which gazelle were still hunted.

It is difficult to determine the date of the abandonment of the settlement. Most of the younger dates of the Neolithic Phase 2B end around 7100 BC; but this is probably due to the course of the calibration curve, which is quite flat until 7100 BC and than drops steeply. The occupation might therefore end earlier. The short-lived cereal samples suggest two relatively brief Neolithic occupation phases, but it has yet to be verified that these two phases are also reflected in the anthropological data.



[1]BM 1719R and OxA 475 were most probably dislocated from more recent layers. BM 1719R also might be considered an example of “old wood effect”. (Mithen and Finlayson 2007 discussed the problem of dating old wood for Wadi Faynan s.p. 31). Two other samples (BM 1122 and OxA 1288) of the Neolithic layers also date to this transitional phase.

[2] The different phases in the diagram (Fig.2) do not correspond to the phases of Moore et al. (2000:257). In order to compare the layers of different trenches, it was necessary to create a new system relying on the stratigraphic positions of the samples.

[3] Two dates, BM 1724R and OxA 1931, are much younger than all the other dates and probably point to a sporadic use of the site after 7000 BC.

[4] The sum of the dates of Phase 2A was calculated without the sample OxA 877, as it could not be attributed clearly to either Phase 2A or 2B.
The ranges of the sum for Phase 2A are: 7790-7770 BC (0.8%); 7760-7440 BC (63.0%); 7410-7360 BC(4.4%).
For Phase 2B they are: 7450-7400 BC (7.9%); 7370-7120 BC (55.2%), 7110-7080 BC (5.1%). The charcoal sample of trench B, BM 1122: 9374 +/- 72 BP dating to around 8500 BC, is probably too old, but it could also derive from the so- called “intermediate period” indicated by several other dates (cf. footnote
2).

 

14C Dates

 Code  BP Dev. Δ13C Location material References
BM 1120 8666 66 Trench E, Phase 3,4,6,7 CH Moore 2000:255
BM 1121 10792 82 E level 2/3 CH Moore 2000:527
BM 1122 9374 72 Trench B, Phase 3 CH Moore 2000:253-255
BM 1423 8676 72 Trench C CH Moore 2000:529
BM 1424 8190 77 Trench B, Phase 7 CH Moore 2000:253-255
BM 1425 8393 72 Trench C, = ca. Phase 8, Trench B CH Moore 2000:529
BM 1718R 11140 140 E447 CH Moore 2000:527
BM 1719 9120 50 ? CH Radiocarbon 24/3,1982,284
BM 1719R 9100 100 Trench E CH Moore 2000:253-255
BM 1721R 8490 110 Trench D, Phase3 CH Moore 2000:253-255
BM 1722R 8640 100 Trench B, Phase 4 CH Moore 2000:253-255
BM 1723R 10820 510 Trench E CH Moore 2000:253-255
BM 1724R 8020 100 Trench E, Phase 6 CH Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 1190 8500 120 Trench B, Phase 2 S (eimmer/eink.) Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 1227 8320 80 Trench G, Phase 3 (younger than Phase 2) CH Moore 2000:255
OxA 1228 9680 90 Trench G, bottom phase 1 CH wood Moore 2000:255
OxA 170 10600 200 E405 S (wild einkorn) Byrd 1994
OxA 171 10600 200 E457 S (wild einkorn) Moore 2000:527
OxA 172 10900 200 E470 S (wild einkorn) Byrd 1994
OxA 1930 8180 100 Trench G, Phase 2 S (wild cereals) Moore 2000:255
OxA 1931 7890 90 Trench G, phase 2 S (dom.wheat) Moore 2000:255
OxA 2167 8270 100 Trench E, Phase 4 S Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 2168 8330 100 Trench E, Phase 5 (above Phase 4) CH Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 2169 8640 110 Trench B, Phase 2 S (einkorn/brly) Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 386 10800 160 E420 S (wild einkorn) Byrd 1994
OxA 387 11070 160 E470 B (bos) Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 397 10420 140 E430 S (wild einkorn) Byrd 1994
OxA 406 9300 250 Trench E B Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 407 10050 180 E419 B Housley 1994:62
OxA 408 10250 160 E419 H Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 430 11020 150 E 460 B, gazelle ch Moore 2000:527
OxA 431 10680 150 E460 H=OxA430 Moore 2000:527
OxA 432 9540 170 Trench E B Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 433 9840 200 Trench E H Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 434 10490 150 E430 B (gazelle, ch) Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 435 10450 180 E430 H=OxA434 Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 4660 8180 200 Trench A, Phase 2 B B Human Moore 2000:528
OxA 468 11090 150 E470 B =OxA 387; bos Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 469 10920 140 E470 H Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 470 10820 160 E470 H Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 471 10620 150 E419 H Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 472 10750 170 E425 H Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 473 10000 170 E425 B (wild sheep ch Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 474 10930 150 E429 B/H (wild sheep) Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 475 9060 140 E 252 B (gazelle, ch) Gowlett, Hedges 1987
OxA 476 9600 200 E430 F(=OxA 434) Gowlett; Hedges 1987
OxA 5842 8260 75 E449 S (splt/br.wheat Moore 2000:528
OxA 5843 8275 65 E449 S (dom. rye) Moore 2000:528
OxA 6336 8140 90 E405 S (dom. einkorn) Moore 2000:528
OxA 6417 8170 90 E411 S (dom wheat) Moore 2000:528
OxA 6418 8115 80 E438 S (dom.barl) Moore 2000:528
OxA 6419 8230 80 E438 S (dom em.) Moore 2000:528
OxA 6685 10930 120 E455 S (dom. rye) Moore 2000:527
OxA 6995 8700 240 Trench E, S (dom einkorn) Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 6996 9860 220 Trench E S (dom. rye) Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 7122 8290 75 E426 S (dom. einkorn) Moore 2000:528
OxA 8718 11140 100 E418 S (dom. rye) Moore 2000:528
OxA 8719 10610 100 E419 S (dom rye) Moore 2000:528
OxA 876 8500 90 Trench D, Phase 1 B, onagger, wild Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 877 8300 150 Trench D, Phase 1 B,sheep/goat Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 879 8570 130 Trench D, Phase4 B,wild onagger Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 881 8870 100 Trench D, Phase 6 (dislocated from a pit) B (sheep/goat) Moore 2000:253-255
OxA 883 11450 300 E470 S (wild einkorn) Housley 1994:62
OxA878 8490 110 Trench D, Phase4 B, wild onagger Moore 2000:253-255

 

 

Associated Projects

Fig.1 Uncalibrated radiocarbon dates of Epi-palaeolithic layers of Abu Hureyra.

(S=seed, SW=wild seed, SD=domesticated seed, SDR=domesticated seed of rye, CH=charcoal, B=bone, BW= wild bone, H=Humic)

 

Fig. 2 Uncalibrated radiocarbon dates of Neolithic phases from Abu Hureyra, arranged according to tenches and material. "Phase" indicates their stratigraphic position within the trenches (legend s. Fig. 1).

     
   
© ex oriente e.V.   |   contact   |   imprint   |   made by datalino 2008-2013 

Ba'ja Projekt

The Significance of Ba'ja for Early
Near Eastern Neolithic Research

The 1997 Season

The 1999 Season

The 2000 Season

The 2001 Season

The 2003 Season

The 2005 Season

The 2007 Season

The 2008 Season

The 2010 Season

Eastern Jafr Project

Eastern Jafr
Joint Archaeological Project

Qulban Beni Murra

Bookshop & Publications

Bookshop

Conditions of Sale

Free Downloads

Neo-Lithics

SENEPSE

Downloads of Articles

About us

About us

ex oriente Publishers

Board

Statutes

Contact

Legal Information

Associated Projects, Cooperations

PPND (Neolithic Radiocarbon Dates)

Neolithic Heritage Trail (u.c.)

Basta Joint Archaeological Projekt (u.c.)

PIGPA Project (u.c.)

'Ain Rahub Project (u.c.)

Cooperations

Donations

Donations (u.c.)

News & Activities

News (u.c.)